The original set of stories dating from the 60's and 70's are all great. The new short story is not, and neither are the bridge chapters. The older stories are sleek tales, where Shaeffer figures out the key puzzle piece and with a narrow margin moves on in one piece himself. Procrustes and its surrounding bridge stories are more of a wheels-within-wheels slog of tale, with several unsavory characters that a smart guy like the Shaeffer of the earlier stories would have automatically avoided. Not worth the small price of the new collection, not worth the reading time.
All of the good stuff can be found in the earlier collections Neutron Star and Tales of Known Space, along with many other excellent short stories Niven produced in the same era. Give Crashlander a pass, buy and read those two other collections. Then use your leftover time to read (or re-read) Protector.
No comments:
Post a Comment